Choosing the right
skin-on-frame kayak for you
Whether you are coming to a class or having a custom kayak
built for you, first you'll have to decide which kayak you
want. I created this short guide to help you make an informed
decision.
First, do you want to go modern or traditional? Traditional
hunting kayaks are undoubtedly alluring but often don't meet the needs
of the modern sea kayaker. Their low volume restricts their
use to day trips only, and for most people the sitting position
(legs almost flat, straight out in front of you) is
difficult to maintain for more than a few hours.
Weathercocking is also an issue, and all greenland kayaks will
frustrate you in a wind coming from the rear quarter.
Finally, they are nearly impossible to self rescue, meaning
that if you don't have a solid roll you shouldn't venture far from
shore alone. I don't want to give the impression that I
don't like Greenland kayaks, I just think it's important to
acknowledge the limitations of the craft so the results meet your
expectations.
Reasons to build a Greenland kayak:
- You already have a sea kayak you like and want to try
something different
- You are interested in kayak history and would like to
pursue traditional greenland rolling techniques
- You think Greenland kayaks look totally awesome (a
common reason, but one few people will admit
Reasons NOT to build a Greenland kayak:
- You weigh more than 200 lbs
- You have any lower back problems
- You want to go camping
- You paddle frequently in windy and rough conditions
If you've decided on a Greenland kayak now to decide which
one. I build a West and an East Greenland traditional
replica kayak. I decided on these two kayaks after building
and testing dozens of historic kayaks and in my opinion they are both
the most well behaved and comfortable for their type. Of
the two, the West Greenland is more comfortable and
versatile, it has the most footroom and weathcocks the least of
any traditional boat I've paddled and it is decently
stable. It's medium length makes it more manuverable and
more fun than most hunting kayaks, and I also build a stretched
out version for larger paddlers who would ordinarily sink the original
version.
The East Greenland kayak is harder to recommend, it's the least
versatile kayak in my lineup, but it is in my opinion also the
most beautiful. Slender, low slung, and swift, this
gorgeous kayak is more than the sum of it's parts.
Modern Kayaks
For people who want the lightness of skin-on-frame but need a more
versatile craft I have two modern designs to choose from, the
F1, and the LPB. The F1 is the "do everything" kayak
that I designed for myself after a lifetime of frustration in modern
touring kayaks. It's equally at home on a week long ocean
tour, playing in fierce surf and winds, or just exploring
the local river or estuary. At 14'3" many people are
worried the F1 won't be fast enough to meet their needs, but in
my experience most people vastly overestimate the speeds they actually
travel and will never reach the "hull speed" of their
kayaks. What this means is that we have a whole generation
of paddlers paying a skin friction/drag penalty for boat lengths they
don't really need. For normal kayak touring speeds of 3-4
mph the F1 isn't just as as fast as these other boats, it's
faster. Reducing the waterline by a couple feet
dramatically reduces the skin friction and this results in a noticable
reduction in paddling effort. Easier paddling is just
the beginning though. By reducing the length we create a
kayak that is better behaved in the wind, easier to manuver, fits
better into sea caves, tight channels, and your garage.
The F1 is a design created not by fashion or dogma, but rather
years and years of testing how we actually use our kayaks. It's the
kayak that I paddle more often than anything else.
Reasons to build an F1
- Versatility
- Manuverability
- Stability
- Comfort
- Ease of paddling
Reasons NOT to build an F1
- You need to sprint faster than 5mph or tour faster than
4 mph
For those of you who feel the need for speed I reluctantly offer the
Long Pointy Boat. Why reluctant? Because most
people who want to build this kayak would be much happier in an
F1. Don't get me wrong, LPB is a great boat, but like
all kayaks increasing the length decreases the playfulness.
Longer boats are less manuverable, less stable, worse in the
wind, and more work to paddle at normal speeds (due to the
increased wetted surface). My point is, if you aren't
pushing hard enough to make use of that waterline, all you've
bought yourself is a worse version of my shorter boat. The
LPB is for the the dedicated fitness paddler who is out there pushing
hard. Want to know if that's you? Grab a cheap
GPS and a kayak and push that baby up to 4.5mph. If at the
end of an hour you're hungry and ready for more, you need an
LPB. If you feel like you're going to blow an artery,
you want an F1.
Reasons to build an LPB
- You need the extra hull speed that waterline affords
and you don't mind sacrificing some manuverability, stability,
versatility, and ease of paddling to get there.
Reasons not to build an LPB
- You don't have the muscle to push it.
Hope this helps, feel free to email me any questions,
Brian- owner/builder/designer
Back to Cape Falcon Kayak